Africa has half as many lions as 20 years ago - but don't blame trophy hunting
The
killing of Zimbabwe's Cecil the Lion has put a welcome spotlight on the
alarming decline of Africa's lions, write Lochran Traill & Norman
Owen-Smith. But to save the species, we should not obsess about trophy
hunting, but tackle much more serious problems - like snaring and
habitat fragmentation.
The halving of Africa's lion population
over 20 years is not the result of trophy hunting. African lions have
declined through the classic drivers of extinction, namely habitat loss,
human-wildlife conflict and disease.
Much of the attention
generated by the demise of Cecil the lion appears related to the fact
that he was a member of a charismatic species, that his species is
threatened and the nature of his death.
But now that Cecil, a
resident of Hwange National Park in Zimbabwe, is gone how do we ensure
that such events are not repeated? It is not as simple as banning
hunting.
Trophy hunting, or the selective removal of animals from a
population based on a desirable trait, is a deeply polarising issue.
Ethical standpoints against the deliberate killing of animals for sport
are what drive the public response that we now see.
Biologists
have concerns about undesirable evolutionary outcomes that may arise
from the killing of 'prime' individual animals. These animals are
typically males that exhibit a desirable trait, like a large mane.
Conservationists
have concerns that hunting may cause inbreeding, or drive rare species'
populations in isolated protected areas to the brink of extinction.
0 comments:
Post a Comment